Putting Manics albums into an order of preference has always been an idea at the back of my head but the thought of actually doing it has always been way too distressing. That is until the mighty JDB had recently been asked to do it. Amazingly he obliged: http:// http://noisey.vice.com/blog/rank-your-records-manic-street-preachers
It’s always interesting to hear the maker’s own analysis of their own output and the way the perspective will always be different from that of the fans. Jame’s overriding reasoning for his order seem rely on two main factors: The enjoyment of the recording process and critical acclaim. I have so much time for what Jamess has to say but am amazed he’s only just realised that every new Manics album is a reaction to the last(!). Manic Street Preachers exist their own bubble. They are not beholden to the nuances of current music scenes. I will also disagree with him on this insistence he has that there are only two versions of the band. For my money there are at least six. I believe every album released has an unidentical twin. Bare with me on this one!
The ambitious, overlong mad as fuck Manics: GT and KYE
The back to basics ten song rock stomper Manics: GATS and SATT
The angry and dark Manics: THB and JFPL
The orchestral, more upbeat Manics: EMG and PFAYM
The “welsh folk” Manics: TIMTMY and RTF
The kind synthy Manics: LB and F
But alas, us fans are a fickle lot. Five minutes in the Forever Delayed forum will make anyone see that. For everyone that see’s my list, 99% of them will be howling derision at it. So get the popcorn ready and feel free to throw it at the screen every time you disagree.
12: LIFEBLOOD (2004)
”And in defeat, cling to these words so clear”
THE GLACIAL ALBUM THAT MELTS THE SOUL BUT FRUSTRATES THE MIND
Perhaps last place is suitable for an album that has the overall feel of the white flag being raised. I was so disconnected from Lifeblood on release. I liked some of the songs but it had the body language of a band slumped over, their fight gone. Strange to think now but I was starting to hope that they would split rather than limp on. I didn’t even attend a tour in 2005, the only one I’ve not been to since 1998. Truth be told, my situation at the time meant it was impossible, I’d have still gone if I could. Typically everyone recalls that Past, Present, Future tour as a spectacular one!
Lifeblood is not a bad album. Far from it. Someone has to be last. 1985, the lost single (registered trademark) gracefully sweeps and swoons. The Love Of Richard Nixon is a song the band have since disowned and I find that a shame, its strange mix of plinky plonky catchiness combined with earnest political satire work wonders. To Repel Ghosts sounds as big and glorious as a big glorious thing. Solitude Sometimes Is a jolty take on loneliness impresses and Cardiff Afterlife is a curious, interesting closer.
Where I struggled then but a bit less so now is here: Not much is being said. There’s no anger, no drive, not even a positive will to want life to be better. It’s sat in the corner sulking on it’s own. I Live To Fall Asleep is a perfect example: “When did you become another distant friend?” we are asked. This is exactly how I felt about my Manics. There are two songs so exasperatingly dull I want to shake them by the neck and scream “WAKE UUUP!” Always/Never makes an attempt at funk sleepworthy, bland as it is in tune and lyrical ‘subject’. Fragments too, mumbles on apologetically. Emily’s line “We used to have answers, now we have only questions, But now have no direction” describes the album in a nutshell.
The sound is pristine and clean, mostly effectively. Like they were trying to wash away the grime. At times though it verges on being just too cold, like looking into its eyes and seeing no soul. Ironically it makes a rather good winter album all told. There are some beautiful moments here, it’s just maybe it could maybe have done with a blood transfusion to help it out a little
Glaring B-side omission: Askew Road
Question: Who the hell is Emily? And does Rachel know about her?
Fact: Secretly this is actually jame’s favourite album but he just likes winding up the fans something chronic.
11: GENERATION TERRORISTS (1992)
“Love your masks and adore your failure”
THE BID FOR WORLD DOMINATION. IT FAILED SLIGHTLY.
There are endless reasons why this debut should be last but let’s cover only some shall we? It’s way too long and has too much filler. Two versions of Repeat?! A cover of Damn Dog? Good lord. The soft rock eighties production is another. Where it should have sounded raucous and punky like The Clash it end up like bloody Meatloaf. A lot of the attitude ends up being strangled by the work of Steve Brown.
What saves it however is the sheer ambition and attitude that drives it forward. The tunes, crammed and overspilling with melody and stangely constructed sentances. An album that contains Motorcycle Emptiness and Stay Beautiful just can’t finish last now can it? Or one that has THAT outro to Condemned To Rock N’ roll.
The lyrics, mostly anyway, defy their youth. Motorcycle Emptiness alone contains more deph than many bands achieve in an entire career: “Culture sucks down words. Itemise loathing and feed yourself smiles. Organise your safe tribal war. Hurt maim kill and enslave the ghetto”. While the call of “BLACK HORSE APOCALYPSE!” is funny as hell in Natwest-Barclays-Midlands-Lloyds’ there is a rich streak (pun intended) of intellect at play. “They give and take away, repossess and crucify. The more you own the more you are lonelier with cheap desire”. Little Baby Nothing is a feminist power ballad co sung by a former porn star – “Loveless slavery, lips kissing empty. Dress your life in loathing. Breaking your mind with Barbie Doll futility”. Only this band, eh?
On release, some fans threatened to kill themselves due to their huge disappointment with the album. To be fair, it’s not THAT bad. Just skip a few songs or even better, listen to the demo version they released recently.
Best sweary moment: “REPEAT AFTER ME! FUCK QUEEN AND COUNTRY!”
Best narrated speech: “Between the billboard masturbation across highways of metallic isolation there lies the deafening screaming of the millions wiping out the diseased pages of apathy that bleed our innocence…”
The clunky lyric award goes to: “Worms in the garden more real than a McDonalds”
Glaring B-side omission: Democracy Coma
Question: Can the person who decided “why don’t you just fuck off” be censored just.. you know.. FUCK OFF
Fact: Damn Dog is shit.
10: REWIND THE FILM (2013)
“There’s too much heartbreak in the nothing of the now”
THE GUITAR WAS PUT TO ONE SIDE AND A BAND FOUND THEIR INNER PEACE
Manics go unplugged. Kind of. Rewind The Film is a subtle and strangely comforting listen.. These are not words normally associated with tem but there’s no need to worry because this isn’t all lovey dovey and soft. It’s an album that questions their own place in the scheme of things and a fear of middle age (which is “somewhere between acceptance and rage) while while looking back with fondness at times past. Stripped back like never before, only one song features an electric guitar. This is effectively their second “welsh folk” album.
Opening track This Sullen Welsh Heart is heartbreaking. A lullaby full of anguish: “I can’t fight this war any more. Time to surrender, time to move on. So line up the firing squads, kiss goodbye to what you want. You can keep on struggling when you’re alone” It can’t hide its resentment either: “The hating half of me has won the battle easily”. Throw in Lucy Rose’s tender vocals and you have perfection. Show Me The Wonder has the feel a wedding band but.. a great one obviously. There is the obligatory Richey love song, As Holy As The Soil (That Buries Your Skin) crumbles hearts the moment it breaks out with the “Oh I love you so won’t you please come home Oh, it’s been so long, I can’t let go” refrain. The album flows gracefully. Instrumental Manorbier goes through peaks and troughs as high as the valleys themselves. Maturity is not an insult in this respect. There are still targets in their sights. Anthem For A Lost Cause concentrates on the miners strikes and the magnificent Tory Baiting “retro-futurism” of 30 Year War closes things in style, preaching about class war and “the endless parade of old Etonian scum”.
If anything, I wish they’d gone more bare, stripped the smooth production back further and made it more lo-fi. They can’t help it, their natural ear for melody and bigness tends to overtake them. There’s a run of four songs that make up the middle section that sound too polished for what they were claiming to achieve. They even sound like outtakes from PFAYM. I know you’re giving the screen evils right now aren’t you?
No shouting, no solos, no gimmicks. Rewind The Films lays them in new territory. Only two version of the band James? AS IF. Rewind The Film is wonderful. And it’s only number sodding nine. For that I am truly sorry.
The clunky lyric award goes to: “I am as tired as John Lennon sang. Conveying exhaustion like no-one else can”
Question: What exactly does Nicky get up to in a hotel room in the middle of nowhere?
Fact: In an attempt to get the “all around the camp fire” vibe for the album the band got stoned and danced naked around one in Sean’s back garden. Sadly Nicky sprained his ankle and moped off to bed.
9: GOLD AGAINST THE SOUL (1993)
“There’s nothing nice in my head, the adult world took it all away”
PROJECT BON JOVI IS GO!
So they didn’t split up. they did however grow facial hair. Signifying a more macho Manics than the glitter twin aesthetic of the debut. If anything Gold Against The Soul’s sound is even more American than its predecessor. A deliberate attempt at FM orientated rock.
This is another one of those albums the band themselves are less keen on but forgetting the setlist classics for now there is much to love in the storm of power chords. Mighty opener Sleepflower (or SLEEEEPFLOOOOWEEERR! as it’s known at gigs for the sheer sole purpose of annoying James.) is an electric tale of insomnia: “I feel like I’m losing pieces of sleep”. Gold Against The Soul’s metallic riff and brooding atmosphere rage as an attack on wealth distribution. Lines like “Shareholding a piece of this fucking country” and “dream of new ways to humble the poor” haven’t dated and are just as relevant today. Symphony Of Tourette is from the perspective of a child with the condition set to a heavy as flip backing “Children can be cruel she said so I smashed her in the fucking head”. I was really surprised that James had a dig at the lyrics on album number two.
Even the weaker moments, where things get a bit too eighties are fun. Drug Drug Druggy’s Chili Peppers-esque beat with it’s “Dance like a robot when you’re chained at the knee” always makes me laugh a little. Nostalgic Pushead (eeew) dirides the rich and fashionable. It’s so absurdly tacky you just have to go along with it.
And then there are the classics. The soaring strings of From Despair To Where which is perhaps an early sign of the EMG era. La Tristesse Durera (Scream To A Sigh) is a shimmying rock ballad about a war veteran.”Wheeled out once a year, a cenotaph souvenir”. Honestly, who else writes this kind of stuff? Roses In The Hospital (“stub cigarettes out on my arm”) is a song that needs to make a return to the setlist and quick.
So this is where the guilt starts kicking in. I really like this album so number ten feels like a ridiculously low place. It’s time to give Gold Against The Soul some much warranted love. Listen to it LOUDLY today and become a slave to its beat, a slave to its chords and a slave to its melancholic pleasure.
Best sweary moment: “We don’t want your FUCKING LOVE”
Glaring B-side omission: Donkeys
Question: SLEEEEEEPFLOWEEEER??!!!
Fact: With reference to Land Becoming A landslide, Richey threw up watching pornography for the first time. He’d be totally appalled by the stuff that’s around today.
8: SEND AWAY THE TIGERS (2007)
“I never knew the sky was a prison”
BACK TO THEIR ROOTS. WITHOUT THE SHIT PRODUCTION.
The band seem to have more affection for Send Away The Tigers than most of the fans but we should all have a soft spot for it as this might just have been the album that saved the Manics. For that we must be grateful alone. They openly admitted it was a clear attempt to get back to the band they were, to find the voice they lost in Lifeblood. It can be taken as nothing other than a success as it has ignited them to a rich vein of form in the eight years since, both live and on record.
Yes, they are in their comfort zone but my God they’re having fun with it. Anthemic, catchy rock pop songs with plenty of oomph, powerhouse drums and solos galore. This might make it sound throwaway but it’s not. There is rhetoric too. The all out boogie-punk of Imperial Bodybags (“life is numbers, with doggy tags”) being an example. Rendition spits venom at fake revolutions. Russell Brand anyone? It must also be said that JDB’s vocals are ON POINT, mixing the newer high range with plenty of old school bellowing.
With typically Manic humour, A song dedicated to the fans (or rather “freaks”) is hated to oblivion by the very people it’s aimed at. Ii is something I don’t understand. One crap edit or not, it kicks arse. The hate amplifies to irrational levels for Autumsong. Any thread on the forum, no matter what subject thread is happening will always lead to “AUTUMNSONG IS SHIT!”. It isn’t, it’s a piece of pop perfection. Deal with it.
There is, however that nagging feeling it could have been even better. the b-sides of this era were pretty spectacular and some could have been included (at the expense of, say Indian Summer!). It would have given a different, darker feel for sure and it’s clear the intention was to get themselves back on track, musically and commercially. Was it too a clinical a motive? Maybe. Be that as it is, it is still a fully charged, unashamedly in your face record that deserves more love.
Best sweary moment: “People like you need too fuck, need to fuck people like me”
The clunky lyric award goes to: “Now baby, what have you done? Done to your hair, done to your hair, done to your hair, done to your hair, hair!”
Glaring B-side omission: Anorexic Rodin
Question: Seriously though, what have you done with your hair?
Fact: The inspiration for Indian Summer was, in the bands words “To write a new version of Design For Life and make it a bit rubbish”
7: FUTUROLOGY (2014)
“I am the sky about to fall in, I am the sea about to part – a tiny piece of malcontent”
ALL HAIL THE PAST, THE PRESENT AND THE FUTUROLOGY
It is not exactly what was promised but when is it ever when it comes to the Manics? It is neither a”post punk indie disco” or “the final in The Holy Bible trilogy”. Once you get past these blatant lies, what we do have is a band near the peak of their powers, urging forward and challenging themselves when they could easily sit back and switch autopilot on. On each track there seems to be a different mission statement as no two sound alike.
‘Let’s Go To War’ rages that “Working class skeletons lie scattered in museums, and all the false economies speak falsely of your dreams” before a united chanting chorus of bile. ‘Europa Geht Durch Mich’ is filled with a heavy funk of European desires. Yes, the Manics and funk. And it works. ‘Dreaming A City (Hughesovka)’ sees the band in new territory too with a big, dreamy synth and bass orgy. Sex, Love, Power And Money is borderline hilarious, mixing synths with their early style.
Lyric wise, Nicky Wire is prone to the odd clunker but this is his most clunker free album to date. Just read “free yourselves from the tyranny of objects, purged of all colour, the purest abstraction” from the gorgeous ‘Black Square’ (inspired by a futurist Russian Opera!) and just marvel. Divine Youth’s synth lullaby complimented by “I sing to myself my civil wars within” and the marvellous “money, it just buys a new way to disguise a freedom you don’t own anymore”.
The influence of Krautrock and the European connection are well integrated and don’t over power proceedings which thankfully leaves it with a clear Manics voice at the core. Indeed, who would have thought an album that features so much Nick Nasmyth would be such a classic? Futurology surprises on all levels.
Best sweary moment: “I bet you felt proud you silly little fucker”
The clunky lyric award goes to: “We’ve all killed some ants. All had broken plans”
Glaring B-side omission: Anti-Social Manifesto
Question: Well do feel proud? HUH?
Fact: Nicky has an unhealthy obsession with bridges.
6: THIS IS MY TRUTH TELL ME YOURS (1998)
“No vendettas – just a cherry blossom tree”
BEAUTIFUL LANDSCAPES OF (NOT VERY MUCH) DISTORTION
The first album without any contribution from Richey this may be but his absence is an almighty influence in the heart of this record. Not just the obvious references to him, but in the gaps where there were less words to play with. A review at the time mentioned it was actually a harder listen in many ways than The Holy Bible and there’s a certain truth in it. It’s stark in places to the point of desperation. The weary I’m Not Working encapsulates the mood well with “No parachutes no dismal clouds, Just this fucking space”. It’s a morbid, keyboard form of a death march. Born A Girl covers Wire’s desire to feel comfortable in his own skin. There’s more.. My Little Empire’s barren loneliness is distressing. Black Dog On My Shoulder’s strings are both beautiful and heartbreaking, an ode to depression played out to devastating effect.
This is the first time the Manics have left room to breath in songs. The atmosphere washes over you without ever grabbing you by the neck and shaking you. The futuristic one about the Spanish civil war ‘If You Tolerate this Your Children Your Children Will be Next, Ready For Drowning and The Everlasting are all grand but subtle anthems. Jame’s voice at the introduction of the latter is uncomfortably intimate on first listens. His voice sounding like it has never done before, less growl and more soul. The songs have less words, less speed in which to fit everything, allowing them to breath like never before.
There are some rockers too, You Stole From The Sun’s grunge bounceabilty and Nobody Loved You is a monster of a love song to Mr Edwards. It’s difficult to know whether to jump about or cry and then at “It’s unreal now you’re gone, but at least you belong” you realise the best thing is to do both. For all the flaws in South Yorkshire Mass Murderer (cut down to SYMM for silly reasons), Nicky still had good intentions but it’s a shame they were so badly executed. No matter as it develops into a brooding, loud musical masterpiece once James stops singing.
This was my first new Manics album to look forward as I’d only been a fan for a year or so. It will always hold a special place in my heart. It speaks to me, maaaan. The fact that I’ve placed it as low as number six seems fucking ridiculous but this is my list, tell me yours.
Best sweary moment: “I’m fucked with being fucked”
The clunky lyric award goes to: “The ending for this song, Well, I haven’t really thought of one”
Best narrated speech: “I will bring the whole edifice down on their unworthy heads”
Glaring B-side omission: Prologue To History:
Question: Let’s be honest, If Nicky really been born a girl he’d never have been able to cope with periods would he?
Fact: The cover shot captures the precise moment James realised he’d left the oven on.
5: EVERYTHING MUST GO (1996)
“All I want to do is live no matter how miserable it is”
BACK FROM THE BRINK.
Firstly, here’s a blog post on how I got into the band with this album:
The Intense Humming Of Doctor Robotnik (And How I Fell In Love With Manic Street Preachers)
Secondly, well where do we start? Everything Must Go is so of it’s time and timeless at the same time. It is the sound of a band brushing themselves down and standing tall, claiming victory from certain defeat.
Of course it’s not exactly a happy album as such, but if you choose not to listen to the lyrics the strings and granduer will take you away to a better place. It’s shiny and glistens loudly. Guitars crash and Jame’s wails like a proper hooligan. It is, it could be said.. intensely intense.
Enola/Alone stomps through nostalgia and ushers in hope for the future. James once stormed out of an interview when told it sounds like Bryan Adams fact fans. No Surface All Feeling scales stratospheric heights with self doubt and hate crashing off each other to raging, screeching guitars and pounding drums. Further Away smashes just how to pull off a love song. It’s so simple with its “the further away I get from you the harder it gets for everyone else” (no, that isn’t rude. Take your minds out of the gutter) but it is intentionally simple.
The one moment it does pause for breath it becomes fragile as hell. ‘Small Black Flowers That Grow In The Sky’, a song about caged zoo animals who “carry your own dead to swing your tyre tricks”. The need to escape is not one of romance but of desperation because “here chewing your tail is joy”. Removables spits and sputters “No-one made the holes but me, Misery mourns to be devoured. Killed God blood soiled unclean again. Killed God blood soiled skin dead again”
The epic, goose bump inducing working class classic A Design For Life may sadly be why people still refer to the band as ‘Britpop’ but without it we wouldn’t have had the Manics for much longer. Myself and the mainstream fell in love with Everything Must Go. It’s one of the few rock albums that people who drive Ford Mondeos’ and work in middle management own. When you next go to Mr & Mrs Smiths house make sure you take a sneak peek at their music collection. It’ll be right there gathering dust with Travis’ The Man Who. And fair enough really, it’s a masterpiece. And I don’t mean The Man Who…
Best sweary moment: “IT’S SO FUCKING FUNNY. IT’S ABSURD”
The clunky lyric award goes to: Yeah, riiiiiiiight.
Question: Who, other than Willem De Kooning sees the interiors like once Willem De Kooning once did?
Glaring B-side omission: Sepia
Fact: There is a small moment in Enola/Alone where James really does sound like Bryan Adams.
4: KNOW YOUR ENEMY (2001)
“Run away, run away as fast as you can from anything that needs discipline”
MANICS LOOSE THE PLOT. AND IT’S FUCKING WONDERFUL.
This really is a VERY manics album in many senses. At the height of their success they went into the studio and consciously decide to fuck things up for themselves. They wanted to sound less polished and in doing so sounded more schizophrenic. I grant you, I wan’t in love at first. It took me a while to fully embrace Know Your Enemy. On hearing So Why So Dad for the first time on the Evening Session (yes, we had to wait by the radio for exclusives to be played – the madness!) a friend and myself were almost crying at the horror. We were not expecting THAT. I love the song now but still, don’t EVER mention the video to me.
Another reason why this a very Manics album? It had an agenda. From the striking sleeve imagery to references to free speech, Civil rights, Cuba and the evil of America. Taking these themes all the way to Cuba itself to launch the album. Meeting Fidel Castro maybe wasn’t the brightest PR move but hey, how Manics is a silly PR move? Very.
In James’ album rankings he described KYE as a malaise? I don’t hear a malaise in the adrenaline of Found That Soul, a sinfully forgotten single. I don’t hear malaise in the scuzzy Dead Martyrs or My Guernica. I don’t hear malaise in the tribute to Paul Robeson. I don’t hear malaise in the USA baiting song for Elián González, with it’s sky scraping chorus. Elsewhere there is plenty more to love. The forlorn anger of His Last Painting, a song that sounds on the verge of either giving up or kicking off. Ocean Spray, James’ tribute to his mother comes replete with crunching kick in AND sean on the trumpet. What do you guys want?!
The reason why Know Your Enemy suffers from aparrent indifference may be due to the sheer variety and surprises on offer. Wattsville Blues has Nicky cod rapping Mark E Smith style over some beats. Miss Europa Disco Dancer is almost a parody of a comedic parody of disco (“Wake up drunk and fall over!”). That mood somewhat changes on its mumbled outro “Braindead motherfuckers, braindead motherfuckers”.
There’s baffle speak too. For all the over the top ryhming that makes up most of Intravenous Agnostic it still delivers a killer in “brutality is needed in capitalist society”. Plus, the ferocity of the drums and layers of guitars more than make up for it. The Convalescent goes on about Haile Gebrselassie, Kleenex tissues and teletext TV but again, the music covers its flaws.
There are two main criticisms of album number six. There are those that really dislike the rough production but for me, on record the band usually sound more polished than they should and here they sound just brilliant. Fierce, grimy and abrasive. Did people really want a third orchestral album in a row? The second, that it is a mess of ideas. That to me is part of its charm. So many ideas, themes and styles. It’s weakness is also its strength. It sounds more spectacular now than it ever did in 2001. Is it too long? Of course it is. Is it the Manics being brave and putting their balls on the line? Of course it is. The Manics knew the enemy had always been themselves. This is that glorious realisation soundtracked.
Best sweary moment: It’s a tie between “Don’t want useless fuckers knocking at my door. Poxy fucking assholes following me . Don’t you understand that I fucking despise every single living organism?” and “Moral little shit-kickers, liberal asinine pricks”.
The clunky lyric award goes to: “You’d love the chance to eat their food. Even though it has been chewed”
Best narrated speech: “Now let the Freedom Train come zooming down the track. Gleaming in the sunlight for white and black. Not stopping at no stations marked colored nor white. Just stopping in the fields in the broad daylight”
Glaring B-side omission: Locust Valley
Question: Is Marilyn Manson’s arse really scared of cash machines and the Mardi Gras? And if so, why?
Fact: Nicky’s sideburns had taken on their own life-form by this point and were given names – Ricky and Micky.
3: JOURNAL FOR PLAGUE LOVERS (2009)
“I am not dead, I demand I know my rights., I know my rights. You cover my illness with flowers and flowers die, flowers die”
RICHEY’S UNSEEN POEMS GIVEN LIFE.
When the Manics announced that they would be releasing an album containing Richey’s words from THAT scrapbook the initial reaction was one of excitement. Then I got nervous and scared and hid behind the sofa. What if… it turned out to be shit? Clearly full of confidence from Send Away The Tigers the band decided they were in the right place to finally revisit the past.
The most startling thing about Journal For Plague Lovers is not only how, for all the talk of The Holy Bible mark two, they never once slip in self parody and that is one of this album’s greatest victories. Thankfully it is not THB mark 2, for we have to remember they were just turning forty when recording this and it would have been awful if they attempted to recreate it. This is a different sounding beast altogether. Quite how an aging band can sound so ahead of anyone else out there while at the same time using fifteen year old words is a miracle in itself.
So, the lyrics then. It’s been known for years that the poems bequeathed (the word of the 2009) were long, rambling and difficult to edit into songs but edit them they did into a collection of short, sharp stabs punk rock. The tone when Richey’s words are at the forefront is always different. They just give the band a certain edge and urgency that isn’t there at other times. The great thing to notice here is that he was evolving further as a poet. While it’s still a mixture of anger and self doubt there’s a different clarity and tonal shift. God forbid, there are even signs of humour in there with Me & Stephen Hawking, a bizarre take on science: “Herman the Bull and Tracey the sheep. Transgenic milk containing human protein. Their bacteria cheaper than baby food. Attention, today it’s a cow, tomorrow it’s you”. In the hands of any other band this would sound ridiculous as would “we missed the sex revolution when we failed the physical” The sentences at times conjure specatular imagery: “Riderless horses on Chomsky’s Camelot” and “Here is oblivion bathed acid red” being just two.
All this soundtracked to a mix of fueled rock and strings. Before it breaks out full throttle ‘Jackie Collins Existential Question Time chugs along to the sort of moral question that all keeps us all up at night: “If a married man fucks a Catholic and his wife dies without knowing, does that make him unfaithful, people?” This Joke Sport Severed darkly broods (“Jealousy sows rejection with a kiss in silken palms that tear bone from skin”) into a gorgeous orchestral conclusion. James barks “I would prefer no choice. One bread, one milk, one food, that’s all. I’m confused, I only want one truth” as All Is Vanity’s riff hammers your skul . Pretension/Repulsion is a messed up up punk headfuck and it’s joyful. Well, maybe joyful isn’t the right word.
There seem to be references from Richey to the time who spent in hospitals and at the priory. Virgina State Epilatic Colony’ is a narky, sarcastic response “today the doctors allow the illusion of choice” and the disorientated chorus “They wake to strobes and half circled light, confusion lifts with potassium percolate”. The title track recalls the bands old interest in religious iconography: “Only a God can bruise, Only a God can soothe. Only a God reserves the right to forgive those that revile him” is certainly a line that fuels further those who believe he may have found God in care though interviews from the time suggest otherwise.
And so to my only complaint… Bag Lady is not officially an album track. It is on my version but according to the track listing and the fact they didn’t play it when they toured the album in full means the band don’t consider it anymore than a bonus track. This is madness even by this bands standards, The contrary bastards. Bag Lady is a sinister, almost morbid attack that teeters between arrogance and self hate. It’s evil riffs combined with words that always give me goosebumps “To be morally good are we ready to love? A devil pretending to be a God” are what would definitely make it into my top ten Manics songs list. Don’t worry though, I will not do that as putting albums into an order has been painful enough. And then.. and then the guitar tears to shreds towards the end and I’m “OH MY FUCKING GOD YES!!”.
.. So that is why I love Bag Lady. And Journal For Plague Lovers. It’s a masterpiece from a band who had no right to be in the position to make a masterpiece. They did Richey Edwards the justice he deserved. As if we had any doubts, eh? This beauty here dipping neophobia, indeed.
Best sweary moment: Already stated!
The clunky lyric award goes to: There isn’t any though it’s thought Nicky’s editing of William’s Last Words reads more like a suicide note than the author intended.
Best narrated speech: “You know so little about me. What if I turn into a Werewolf or something?”
Question: Did Giant haystacks really wrestle in front of 100,000 people?
Fact: Sean actually wrote the lyrics to this album. Richey played drums.
2: POSTCARDS FROM A YOUNG MAN (2010)
“This world will not impose its will. I will not give up and I will not give in”
THE CORE OF MANICS FANS HATE IT WITH A PASSION. BUT THEN NOT MUCH PLEASES ‘EM SO…
No, I am not joking. Yes, this is my second favourite album. Postcards is the black sheep of the family, just mentioning it seems to send people out in hives. It is the most hated of them all. The “one last shot at communication” soundbite seemed to get people’s backs up from the start. Strange, considering the band have never been shy about wanting commercial success. It was an album I loved pretty much all of from the very first listen. I previously stated the positive affect Everything Must Go had on me but add that ten fold to this album. 2009 and 2010 were bleak times personally. I’ll spare you the details but I definitely didn’t need a new angry/downbeat Manics album at that time and thankfully they didn’t deliver one. It was perfect for me.
There’s lot’s of abuse aimed at Postcards. It’s “lifeless” and “dull” to the critics. All I can say is – You are listening to it WRONG. It zips along at a wonderful pace. The production also gets stick as being too glossy but to my ears it’s brash and loud. A perfect mix of strings and choirs with fierce sounding guitar crunches and solos. The band’s world weary cynicism still shows through but it’s to a different beat. New dynamics added along with the kitchen sink.
My love for the title track knows no bounds. Some Kind Of Nothingness has a yearning other worldly beauty. Hazelton Avenue take’s Lenny Kravitz’ It ‘Ain’T Over ‘Til It’s Over’ and pushes it over the edge into an ode to finding peace in the solitary. On first listen to I Think I Found It I was concerned that James had joined a hippy commune or worse… the big man himself. So positive sounding and at ease with itself and so totally un-Manics. “We’ve finally found a way to consume boredom everyday” James yells to the opening chugs of anti technology anthem ‘A Billion Balconies Facing The Sun’ as it builds into a proper barnstormer. Yeah. Barnstormer.
‘All We Make Is Entertainment’ is a romp that plays out a loss of working values. It reminds me musically of The Jam and not because the word entertainment is in the title. The discordant optimism of ‘The Future has been Here 4ever’ provides us with Nicky’s strongest vocal to date (ok, so there isn’t much competition on that front). Maybe it’s because he’s being battled by an upbeat choir serenading us with the strangely positive “let some love break through the light, let someone come into your life”. Again, so totally un-Manics in spirit and brilliantly so. Don’t Be Evil tirades against the self obsession the internet exacerbates “Fool the world with all your own importance.
Portray your tedium for the world to see”. These are magnificent tunes, people!
Also, it must be said I believe PFAYM to be Jame’s strongest ever vocals. Amid all the lovely stuff there’s plenty of sneering and shouting going on too. His voice is an absolute powerhouse here. The lyrics too, like the album itself are undervalued. Ignored even. I try not to get too defensive when everyone slags off my beloved Postcards. Music is all down to personal taste and experiences after all. To my ears this is a band firing on all cylinders. Confident, exuberant, loud and beautiful all in one. It even gets abuse for being “unsubtle”. Guys, you do realise the Manics are rarely connoisseurs of subtlety, right? So yes, this album helped me then as it does now. To quote Auto-Intoxication “I am so lucky. I think that I survived”. Indeed I did. And this album was one of the reasons.
Best sweary moment: There isn’t any. This means only two albums are cuss free.
The clunky lyric awards: “I hope I’m making sense. I’ve lost my last defence. This is my last descent”
Glaring B-side omission: I’m Leaving you For Solitude
Question: Does anyone know what James actually found?
Fact: No, sod it. Everybody who says this is their worst LP is wrong. FACT.
1: THE HOLY BIBLE (1994)
“The centre of humanity is cruelty”
THE MOST RIGHT WING OF ALBUMS FROM THIS MOST LEFT WING OF BANDS. NOT EXACTLY ABBA GOLD
How depressing predictable. The album that not long ago was recently been voted “the most depressing album of all time” has reached my personal number one. Make no mistake, this is not easy listening. It is hard work at times, it can worm it’s way into your mind and senses. For all I’ve praised EMG and PFAYM for the positivity they’ve brought to my life, The Holy Bible can be responsible for the opposite. It is its own mood piece, it’s own sinister dimension. Totally at odds with the world and itself and raging against both. The listener soon feels at odds with both too. But one has to question if it really is the most miserable collection of songs in history. For all the subject matter: Prostitution, castration of men, serial killers, anorexia and the holocaust to name the greatest hits(!) there is a pure heart at the centre of it all. Albeit set to a spitting, seething brutal noise.
Compromise. We all do it. The Manics have done it quite a few times over the years but the everlasting legacy if any that The Holy bibles should imprint on music is it’s stance – stood aggressively tall, arms folded and flicking the v’s. There is an outright insistence to stick to their guns and release what felt right. No recording in mansions, just three musicians in a crammed studio in the red light district of Cardiff (with Richey playing is Sega somewhere else). In short, The Holy Bible is uncompromising. The first four words are “For sale, dumb cunts same dumb questions”
So to the words then, where do we begin? It is the voice of no generation. Britpop was kicking into gear and here was the Manics sounding out “Killers view themselves like they view the world, they pick at the holes. Not punish less, rise the pain. Sterilise rapists, all I preach is EXTINCTION” on Archives Of Pains’ heavy bass and apoplectic meltdown with the most ludicrously catchy chorus to boot. The marching strides of 4st 7lbs vocalises the horror of anorexia with such honesty it almost makes it sound beautiful: “I want to walk in the snow and not leave a footprint. I want to walk in the snow and not soil its purity”. That’s a key factor in this album, the work from both Richey AND Nicky are either so honestly blunt or so extremely… out there. The opener Yes yells “He’s a boy, you want a girl so tear off his cock, Tie his hair in bunches, fuck him, call him Rita if you want”. The sole moment of serenity, musically at least comes in the form of the dejected paean This Is yesterday (“I repent, I’m sorry, everything is falling apart”)
The music has a feel of being trapped in a metal cage and fighting to get out. Everything feels pressurised. The noise and words all spilling out but the soul still stuck inside. Of Walking Abortion, inspired by SCUM (Society For Cutting Men) is a vicious attack with a black heart: “Little people in little houses like maggots small blind and worthless”. Faster pulverises a mantra of self loathing and makes it sound so so.. fun. The Intense Humming Of Evil is literally six minutes of intense humming. A robotic, claustrophobic dirge on the holocaust that manages to say a line as offensive as “Lives that wouldn’t have changed a thing. Never counted – never mattered – never be” without even flinching.
The recent anniversary gigs would suggest this album isn’t quite as depressing as is made out. We jumped, we sang and we cried. Fair enough, we didn’t exactly laugh but if you really want depressing you’re better off listening to some Nick Drake. There’s a reason for this. It’s because the music so masterfully crafted by James and Sean to not only (almost) fit these essays is a work of genius in itself but against all odds, the tunes are mighty, powerful AND you can sing along to them. Well, most of them. Quite simply, there has never been an album that sounds like The Holy Bible and nor will there ever be again. It is unique. It is its own musical landscape. It is its own rage and ultimately its own self fulfilling prophecy. Quite frankly, I’d be here so long writing about this album alone it’d be a dissertation in itself. Now there’s an idea…
Best sweary moment: “Whose responsible? YOU FUCKING ARE!”
The clunky lyric award goes to: SOD. RIGHT. OFF
Best narrated speech: “I knew that someday I was gonna die and I knew before I died two things would happen to me. That number one: I would regret my entire life And number two: I would want to live my life over again”
Question: Who do you think are?! You damn well think you’re God or somethi.. oh wait. Sorry. I thought you were someone else.
Fact: This is the greatest album of all time.
You must be logged in to post a comment.